Cattaraugus County, NY Recreational Land, Commercial Properties for Sale with Recently Sold Properties

This secluded hunting cabin on 3 acres includes all amenities and is just down the road from Pine Hill State Forest. This 600 sq. ft. cabin has 2 spacious bedrooms with another bedroom in the loft, full bathroom, open living room/dining room area off

Sold Mar 19, 2021

$64,9003 acres

3 beds1 baths600 sqft

Oldro Hill Road, Randolph, NY, 14772, Cattaraugus County

Welcome to 7105 Alderbottom Road in South Dayton, NYa cozy 2-bedroom, 1-bath cottage-style home set on approximately 7.9+/- picturesque acres of a sloped, wooded terrain. Built in 1978, this 560-square-foot retreat offers rustic charm, privacy, and t

Recreational Property for sale in Cattaraugus County, New York

Under Contract

$149,9007.9 acres

2 beds1 baths560 sqft

7105 Alderbottom Rd, Conewango Valley, NY, 14726, Cattaraugus County

Building a dream home on a hill couldn’t be better than on a dead end road overlooking beautiful fall color on hills and ridges with family farms below in the valley. This property is suited well for building on your choice of multiple areas to suit

Sold Sep 10, 2021

$114,90043 acres

12905 Mud Lake Road LotWP#001, Kennedy, NY, 14747, Cattaraugus County

This house, barn, and garage sit on 4.85 acres includes Free Gas and has amazing hillside views in Olean NY, Cattaraugus County. The homes first story has a large open kitchen, 1 bedroom, 1 full bathroom, 2 living rooms, and 2 mudroom entrances. The

Under Contract

$194,9004.85 acres

4 beds2 baths2,976 sqft

1902 East River Road, Olean, NY, 14760, Cattaraugus County

Travis Thurston

Ever dreamed of owning a Certified Organic farm? This one is unique, specializing in several varieties of squash. Spaghetti, acorn, butternut, delicata and carnival are a few types grown in fertile and nutrient soil here. Secondary is a U-pick portio

Sold Sep 10, 2021

$179,90058.5 acres

12905 Mud Creek Lot#WP001, Kennedy, NY, 14747, Cattaraugus County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present this exceptional hilltop dream home. Experience the tranquility of country living in this stunning brand-new construction ranch-style home on a quiet road. Situated on a beautiful property with breathtaking

Sold May 16, 2023

$414,90050 acres

3 beds2 baths1,390 sqft

5292 Steward Road, Hinsdale, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present a beautiful property quaintly hidden just a third of a mile from the Golden Hill State Forest in Humphrey, NY. Upon approach from County Rt 18 (Humphrey Road), a newly graded and graveled driveway leads you

Sold Dec 11, 2023

$149,90054.2 acres

4204 Humphrey Rd, Great Valley, NY, 14741, Cattaraugus County

Looking for your very own slice of paradise? Look no further than this stunning 45.6-acre property in Hinsdale, NY, complete with a 38.9' camper trailer that sleeps 10!This gorgeous property features everything you need for a comfortable and exciting

Sold Mar 20, 2024

$169,90045.6 acres

431 Yankee Road, Hinsdale, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

In the lil village of Conewango, and in the rolling hills of Southwestern Cattaraugus county sits a small parcel of 1.8 acres with a large home and barn surrounded by neighboring farms. The farmette has multiple gated entrances from Seagar Hill Road

Sold May 30, 2023

$109,9001.8 acres

5 beds2 baths2,560 sqft

12019 Seager Hill Road, Conewango Valley, NY, 14726, Cattaraugus County

A quiet country farm with two barns, a workshop, tillable acreage and a large house sits quaintly just outside the village of South Dayton, NY. This farm currently operates as two businesses. The first is a calving operation with 110 stalls for raisi

Sold Jul 12, 2022

$229,90026.6 acres

6 beds3,072 sqft

12671 Bentley Road, South Dayton, NY, 14138, Cattaraugus County

Looking for that right-sized parcel to build a country home on or park a camper? We are pleased to present a beautiful lot just minutes from Randolph, NY. This parcel orients west and gently slopes a mere twenty feet from the road frontage to the bac

Sold Mar 23, 2023

$64,9999.7 acres

Rte 394, Lot #1, Cold Spring, NY, 14772, Cattaraugus County

Sold Mar 23, 2023

$64,9999.7 acres

Rte 394, Lot #2, Cold Spring, NY, 14772, Cattaraugus County

In the heart of dairy country in the Conewango Valley sits this level parcel of fertile soils for pasture, hay and corn ground. Fenced off into several fields with access for farming practices, this compliment of land is suitable for rotational plant

Sold Apr 28, 2025

$454,900167 acres

VL Cowens Corners Rd, Lot#WP001, Conewango Valley, NY, 14726, Cattaraugus County

135 acres with beautiful 4 bedroom, 2.5 bath house, airplane hangar, and airstrip in Frewsburg NY bordering South Valley State Forest. The house has been totally renovated including new hardwood and tile flooring. Spacious kitchen with a lot of cupbo

Sold Sep 25, 2020

$549,900135 acres

4 beds2 baths2,270 sqft

11791 Bone Run Road, Frewsburg, NY, 14738, Cattaraugus County

This 65 acres is an excellent hunting and recreational property with mature timber located in Limestone NY, Cattaraugus County. The property is mostly hardwoods with a few scattered pines throughout. There is an abundant amount of mature timber throu

Sold Jun 24, 2024

$194,90065.1 acres

676 Main Street, Limestone, NY, 14753, Cattaraugus County

Travis Thurston

Amazing split level, 4 bedroom house has it all! Secluded home with a wrap-around porch around the whole house. This home includes a large, open concept kitchen with lots of cupboards and counter top space with a bar to enjoy meals and conversations.

Sold May 1, 2019

$259,90014.4 acres

4 beds2 baths3,000 sqft

2032 Wayman Branch Road, Olean, NY, 14760, Cattaraugus County

Well-maintained farm with tillable ground, hardwoods, and streams in Hinsdale NY, Cattaraugus County. Beautiful 4 bedroom, 2 bath farmhouse with many interior and exterior updates including new windows, insulation, metal roof, vinyl siding and recent

Sold Jul 18, 2018

$259,900116 acres

4 beds2 baths1,969 sqft

4497 Gile Hollow Road, Hinsdale, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present this beautiful and scenic property in Hinsdale, NY. Featuring a creek in the lowest elevation that spans the length of the property east and west called Scott Branch, this scenic property has a view from the

Sold May 23, 2023

$79,90035.7 acres

Sherlock Hollow Road, Hinsdale, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

119 acres with a 2 bedroom house, pond and beautiful views in Ischua NY, Cattaraugus County. This nice 2 bedroom, 2 bath home includes a spacious kitchen with stainless steel appliances, lots of cabinets, and a breakfast bar large enough for the whol

Sold Sep 3, 2019

$244,900119 acres

2 beds2 baths832 sqft

1052 Johnson Hollow Road, Ischua, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

Sold Nov 16, 2016

9471 Sawmill Run Road, Napoli, NY, 14755, Cattaraugus County

Beautiful, well-built cabin with 13 acres consisting of a nice mix of red pine and hardwoods for great hunting. The cabin is 8 x 12 and is fully insulated. Entering the cabin, which is finished with knotty pine, creates a very comfortable feeling. It

We are pleased to present a large hunting parcel located just minutes from the town of Cattaraugus, NY. Arriving at the property, it is easy to find with intersection access near Rt 380 and Snyder Hill Road. Entering the property here, you will find

Sold

$159,90072.5 acres

VL Snyder Hill Road, Lot#WP001, Cattaraugus, NY, 14719, Cattaraugus County

This 17-acre building lot offers a nice blend of open space and wooded privacy, with sweeping views overlooking the Western New Land Conservancy, and migrating and local waterfowl can be enjoyed and observed. With 495 feet of road frontage and electr

Sold

$87,90017.1 acres

VL Pigeon Valley Rd, Lot#WP001, Little Valley, NY, 14755, Cattaraugus County

We are pleased to present a beautiful and quiet country living ranch located just minutes from downtown Olean and Portville with 1,538 feet of Allegany River frontage. Enjoy the quiet life on a dead end road surrounded by towering pines and views ove

Sold Jun 13, 2024

$369,90068.1 acres

863 Smith Road, Olean, NY, 14760, Cattaraugus County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present a hidden property right on the edge of town. Merely 1/3 of a mile north of the town limits of Salamanca, NY, this hidden property was once the thriving business called Valley Kennels. From the road frontage,

Sold Dec 14, 2023

$295,90012.4 acres

4 beds2 baths2,392 sqft

4147 Center Street Extension, Salamanca, NY, 14779, Cattaraugus County