Allegany County, NY Recently Sold Timberland Properties, Horse Properties

This recreational parcel is near several state forest lands, Letchworth State Park, and the Genesee River, among other attractions. With approximately 40 feet of road frontage and a trail system throughout, this diverse acreage can provide multiple u

Sold Sep 29, 2024

$54,90015 acres

County Route 15, Lot#WP001, Fillmore, NY, 14735, Allegany County

Well-maintained country home on 32 acres in Wellsville NY, Allegany County. Situated along a paved road in southern Allegany County is this ranch-style home with a detached garage and large pole barn. Built in 1995, the country home has 3 bedrooms an

Sold Mar 22, 2023

$299,90032.6 acres

3 beds2 baths1,980 sqft

1995 Forsythe Road, Wellsville, NY, 14895, Allegany County

Sold Nov 14, 2024

54 Conley Rd, Cuba, NY, 14727, Allegany County

Located on a seasonal road just south of Cuba, your slice of heaven awaits. All of the creature comforts are available at this secluded two-bed, one-bath cabin with views across the valley. Enjoy a morning cup of coffee sitting on the front porch or

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present a newly constructed home with a barn and privacy in Belfast, NY. This 2022 build has country living and hobby farm charm. Upon approach the home can’t be readily seen from the road as you drive up the drivew

Sold Oct 10, 2023

$164,9002.1 acres

7055 Cloverleaf Road, Belfast, NY, 14711, Allegany County

Amazing country retreat with a 2 bedroom cabin, views, woods and a large pond on 96 acres in Burns NY. Lots of opportunity with this property! This turn-key, two bedroom cabin is currently used as a retreat. Excellent investment opportunity to create

Sold Sep 26, 2023

$349,90096.4 acres

2 beds1 baths1,080 sqft

9929 State Route 961F, Burns, NY, 14807, Allegany County

This Horse Farm includes a home, barns, and a riding arena on 49 acres. Situated just outside the Village of Andover in southern Allegany County is this well-kept equine facility. Take the paved driveway leading to the home that sits off the road ove

Sold Oct 14, 2024

$439,90049.7 acres

3 beds2 baths1,920 sqft

1759 NY-417, Andover, NY, 14806, Allegany County

This country property includes a house, barn, and fenced pasture on 19+ acres located in Friendship NY, Allegany County. Welcome to your dream country home! This picturesque property offers breathtaking views, serene seclusion, and is located on a qu

Sold Feb 6, 2025

$179,90019.3 acres

2 beds1 baths1,452 sqft

69 Depot Street, Friendship, NY, 14739, Allegany County

This 244 acre property consists of timberland with a stream in Friendship NY. Enjoy the seclusion and diversity of this large recreational property situated along Van Campen Creek. Enter the property through the private gated drive, a deeded right-of

Sold Feb 29, 2024

$384,900244 acres

Tuckers Corners Road, Friendship, NY, 14739, Allegany County

Nice split-level country home with 4 bedrooms on 23 acres in Ward NY bordering State Forest. This home includes a finished full basement which leads into a large mud/utility room. From the utility room there is a cozy and bright living room with a wo

Sold Jun 7, 2019

$159,90023.3 acres

4 beds2 baths2,301 sqft

5151 Wadsworth Hill Road, Scio, NY, 14880, Allegany County

Well-maintained 3 bedroom house with barns, guest house, sugar shack, and pole barn in Angelica NY, Allegany County. The first floor of the house consists of kitchen with oak cabinets and bar, bright and spacious dining and living room with pellet st

Sold Sep 24, 2018

$181,90015.5 acres

3 beds2 baths1,104 sqft

6085 Feathers Creek Road, Belmont, NY, 14813, Allegany County

This house has 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, 1,456 sq. ft. and is located in Arkport NY. Enter this home into a laundry room with a large mudroom. The custom kitchen has extended countertops and plenty of cupboard space. The open concept dining room-

Sold Mar 7, 2024

$149,90017.9 acres

3 beds2 baths1,456 sqft

8833 Brown Road, Arkport, NY, 14807, Allegany County

Travis Thurston

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present this scenic off-grid hilltop property near Bolivar, NY! This property is truly a wonderful find, with its high elevation offering beautiful views of the Allegany Hills. Accessed via Anderson Hollow Road, the

Sold Apr 25, 2023

$89,90056.7 acres

Kansas Hollow Road, Lot#WP001, Bolivar, NY, 14715, Allegany County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present your dream retreat! This incredible property offers the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience, making it an ideal haven for those seeking a quiet and private escape. Nestled in a serene location close

Sold Jun 19, 2023

$79,90013.3 acres

5590 Bill Allen Hill, Wellsville, NY, 14895, Allegany County

Welcome to this beautiful home and acreage located in Alfred NY. History lives in this property! Known as the Gabriel Homestead, the home was built by Archie and Arlene Shaw in 1905. The housing blocks and the roofing tiles were made in Alfred. This

Sold Jun 21, 2023

$539,900138 acres

4 beds2 baths1,908 sqft

5624 State Route 21, Alfred, NY, 14803, Allegany County

Great opportunity to own your own farm in Friendship NY with majority of the land being tillable. This 68 acre farm includes a house, cattle barn, tillable farmland and fenced-in pasture and is located on a dead end road. Amazing views and a perfect

Sold Jun 15, 2020

$159,90068 acres

72 Depot Street, Friendship, NY, 14739, Allegany County

54+ acres with log-sided home and building in Allen NY, Allegany County. This 2 bedroom, 1 full bath home is currently being used as a camp but has been a residential home for many years prior to being used as a camp. The home has an open concept flo

Sold Jul 14, 2017

$124,90054.4 acres

9175 West Hill Road, Fillmore, NY, 14735, Allegany County

Immaculate home in Rushford NY, Allegany County on 10 acres. Amazing 3,000+ sq. ft. home with stunning valley views! The home includes 3 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, large kitchen with a walk-in pantry, living room with hardwood floors and a deck accessed fr

Sold Oct 31, 2019

$298,90010 acres

3 beds2 baths3,103 sqft

8508 Baldwin Hill Road, Caneadea, NY, 14717, Allegany County

Nice 3 bedroom log home on 5 acres with barn, pasture and stream in Granger NY, Allegany County. This home includes a kitchen, living room, dining room and a large mud room with washer and dryer hook ups. There is fire-view coal stove with a stone-fa

Sold Sep 10, 2018

$119,9005.1 acres

3 beds1 baths790 sqft

4887 Gleason Road, Hunt, NY, 14846, Allegany County

This secluded country home is accompanied by a barn, pond, pasture, and woods located in the hills of Allegany County, NY. This farmhouse boasts many new features from 2024, including, but not limited to, a new 200 AMP electric service to the house,

Sold

$399,90020 acres

4 beds1 baths2,316 sqft

5334 Spring Brook Road, Friendship, NY, 14739, Allegany County

This secluded 70 acre property includes a mobile home, garage and jeep located in Scio NY. This would be perfect for a hunting and family get-away. The acreage consists of mainly hardwoods such as red and white oak, and shagbark hickory, along with a

Sold Apr 18, 2023

$134,90070.2 acres

5090 Snowball Hollow Road, Scio, NY, 14880, Allegany County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present an all-organic cattle/dairy farm for sale just south of Centerville NY. This scenic farm boasts an updated constructed home of over 4,000 sqft, with nine bedrooms, two bathrooms and a wraparound porch that i

Sold Oct 29, 2024

$324,90043 acres

10028 West Centerville Road, Houghton, NY, 14735, Allegany County

We are pleased to present a beautiful and scenic hilltop vegetable farm in Fillmore. This farm has a 2200 sqft ranch home that overlooks the entire farm. With four bedrooms and two baths, it has plenty of room and also has a full-height basement. Clo

Sold Oct 15, 2024

$324,90025.9 acres

10228 County Road 23, Fillmore, NY, 14735, Allegany County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present an exceptional hunting and recreational property in Almond, NY! This 54-acre property is a hunter's paradise and is located adjacent to the 4,744 acres of Turnpike State Forest, providing you with endless op

Sold Jun 22, 2023

$119,90054.1 acres

1320 McHenry Valley Rd, Almond, NY, 14804, Allegany County

This home offers great potential for investors or as a single family home. You could pay for most of your mortgage by renting one side of the property and living in the other. This duplex has 2 bedrooms and 1 and a half baths on each side. Each side

Sold Apr 16, 2021

$64,9001.53 acres

4 beds2 baths2,240 sqft

90 East Dyke Street, Wellsville, NY, 14895, Allegany County