Allegany County, NY Recreational Land, Horse Properties for Sale with Recently Sold Properties between 11 and 50 Acres

Located on a seasonal road just south of Cuba, your slice of heaven awaits. All of the creature comforts are available at this secluded two-bed, one-bath cabin with views across the valley. Enjoy a morning cup of coffee sitting on the front porch or

Sold Nov 14, 2024

$169,90021.9 acres

2 beds1 baths

54 Conley Rd, Cuba, NY, 14727, Allegany County

This 43.6 acres is a great recreational property and a great spot for your cabin or home in Allen NY. The acreage consists of a nice brush-hogged field with amazing views, and the remaining acreage consists of hardwoods with some softwood trees. Ther

Sold Jan 8, 2024

$98,90043.6 acres

Wigwam Road, Angelica, NY, 14711, Allegany County

This Horse Farm includes a home, barns, and a riding arena on 49 acres. Situated just outside the Village of Andover in southern Allegany County is this well-kept equine facility. Take the paved driveway leading to the home that sits off the road ove

Sold Oct 14, 2024

$439,90049.7 acres

3 beds2 baths1,920 sqft

1759 NY-417, Andover, NY, 14806, Allegany County

We are pleased to present a hill top property with views and a multitude of uses in Friendship, NY. this beautiful parcel has 494 feet of road frontage on Maple Grove Road . This property is mostly low brush and overgrown field that could easily be r

Sold Nov 9, 2023

$89,90047.5 acres

Maple Grove Road, Lot#WP002, Friendship, NY, 14739, Allegany County

Well-maintained 3 bedroom house with barns, guest house, sugar shack, and pole barn in Angelica NY, Allegany County. The first floor of the house consists of kitchen with oak cabinets and bar, bright and spacious dining and living room with pellet st

Sold Sep 24, 2018

$181,90015.5 acres

3 beds2 baths1,104 sqft

6085 Feathers Creek Road, Belmont, NY, 14813, Allegany County

This house has 3 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, 1,456 sq. ft. and is located in Arkport NY. Enter this home into a laundry room with a large mudroom. The custom kitchen has extended countertops and plenty of cupboard space. The open concept dining room-

Sold Mar 7, 2024

$149,90017.9 acres

3 beds2 baths1,456 sqft

8833 Brown Road, Arkport, NY, 14807, Allegany County

Travis Thurston

Wonderful 45 acre seasonal retreat, ideal for recreation and hunting enthusiasts. This property primarily features a diverse mix of hardwood timber, complemented by several acres of nut trees. It boasts well maintained four-wheeler trails throughout.

Sold Mar 11, 2024

$99,90045 acres

6718 Phillips Hill Rd, Bolivar, NY, 14715, Allegany County

29 acres of hunting and recreational land bordering Phillips Creek State Forest in Alfred NY. The land is mostly level with a good mixture of hardwood trees and pine trees. There is an established driveway with roughly an acre of open land that would

Sold Jul 31, 2023

$74,90029 acres

Hemlock Hill Road, Alfred, NY, 14803, Allegany County

Travis Thurston

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present your dream retreat! This incredible property offers the perfect blend of tranquility and convenience, making it an ideal haven for those seeking a quiet and private escape. Nestled in a serene location close

Sold Jun 19, 2023

$79,90013.3 acres

5590 Bill Allen Hill, Wellsville, NY, 14895, Allegany County

Looking for a good hunting or recreational property near multiple state forests? This is a parcel abundant with wildlife signs. A shared deeded Right of Way takes you to this parcel, where a camping or off-grid cabin could be established. The partial

Sold Jul 14, 2023

$49,90015 acres

2482 Davidson Road #15, Arkport, NY, 14807, Allegany County

This off-grid log home sits on 45 acres and borders state land located in Belfast NY, Allegany County. This incredible property could be a family retreat, hunting camp, and an excellent investment opportunity with available marketable timber. Nestled

Recreational Property for sale in Allegany County, New York

Under Contract

$224,90045.1 acres

3 beds1,344 sqft

6222 Belvidere Rd, Belfast, NY, 14711, Allegany County

Escape to the serenity of nature with this charming cabin and retreat, nestled in a private oasis near Friendship, NY. This rustic yet comfortable cabin or home offers the perfect getaway for outdoor enthusiasts, hunters, and those seeking a peaceful

Sold Nov 28, 2023

$164,90021.3 acres

3684 Hicks Hill Road, Wirt, NY, 14739, Allegany County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present an all-organic cattle/dairy farm for sale just south of Centerville NY. This scenic farm boasts an updated constructed home of over 4,000 sqft, with nine bedrooms, two bathrooms and a wraparound porch that i

Sold Oct 29, 2024

$324,90043 acres

10028 West Centerville Road, Houghton, NY, 14735, Allegany County

We are pleased to present a beautiful and scenic hilltop vegetable farm in Fillmore. This farm has a 2200 sqft ranch home that overlooks the entire farm. With four bedrooms and two baths, it has plenty of room and also has a full-height basement. Clo

Sold Oct 15, 2024

$324,90025.9 acres

10228 County Road 23, Fillmore, NY, 14735, Allegany County

20 acres with pond, camper, and shed bordering Bully Hill State Forest in Almond NY. A great country property located along two gravel roads with an existing driveway leading to the camp site. There is a camper on site with electric hook-up and a dec

Sold Sep 11, 2020

$47,90020.9 acres

Ryan Road, Almond, NY, 14804, Allegany County

We are pleased to present a parcel of land with several attractors. With over 600 feet of frontage, it is suitable for building a home or cabin. The Sellers have enjoyed over 300 maple syrup taps on tube and could easily expand the property for more.

Sold Nov 13, 2024

$85,00031.7 acres

8044 Stone Spring Rd, Centerville, NY, 14029, Allegany County

This 23 acres is an excellent hunting and recreational property which includes a pond, travel trailer, garage, and shop located in Wirt NY, Allegany County. This property offers a well-established setup ready for various uses. It includes a travel tr

Under Contract

$129,90023.1 acres

6355 Wells Road, Wirt, NY, 14739, Allegany County

Cozy 3 bedroom home with barn in Allen NY, Allegany County. This rustic home is located in a quiet area offering great privacy. The home includes an open concept first floor with a kitchen, one bedroom, full bath, laundry room, wood stove, and wood f

Sold Jun 29, 2020

$109,90015.8 acres

3 beds1 baths1,152 sqft

8511 West Hill Road, Belfast, NY, 14711, Allegany County

11 acres nice country home with beautiful valley views in West Almond NY. This property has been used a seasonal home for many years. Located in a quiet area on a year-round maintained road. The home includes 2 bedrooms, 1 full bath, open concept kit

Sold Nov 10, 2020

$79,90011.4 acres

2 beds1 baths1,040 sqft

2530 Turnpike Road, Almond, NY, 14804, Allegany County

12 acres hunting land with newly built barn in New Hudson NY, Allegany County. The acreage is almost completely wooded with a mixture of hardwoods, apple trees and scattered pines. The land is rolling with a ravine, and there is a creek running throu

Sold May 10, 2023

$79,90012.9 acres

New Mexico Road, Cuba, NY, 14727, Allegany County

Travis Thurston

Beautiful country acreage with secluded home, garage and pond in Angelica NY. This property is currently used as a seasonal residence but is suitable for full-time residence. The home includes 2 bedrooms, 1 full bathroom, kitchen, living room with a

Sold Feb 28, 2020

$148,90032.2 acres

2 beds1 baths616 sqft

7262 Frace Road, Belfast, NY, 14711, Allegany County

Secluded on the crown of a mountain top near Andover, NY, is a spectacular building lot for your cabin or dream home. Overlooking a pond and vista views south, this parcel is tucked away on a dead-end road where privacy and summer breezes await you.

Sold Feb 1, 2023

$139,90038 acres

North Hunter's Road, Lot#WP001, Andover, NY, 14806, Allegany County

Escape to the serenity of nature with this charming cabin and retreat, nestled in a private woodland setting near Allentown, NY. This rustic yet comfortable cabin offers the perfect getaway for outdoor enthusiasts, hunters, and those seeking a peacef

Sold Mar 19, 2024

$159,99916 acres

VL McKee Road, Lot#WP001, Bolivar, NY, 14715, Allegany County

27+ acres hunting land and timberland bordering State Land in West Almond NY, Allegany County. Perfect for the sportsman and hunter! West Almond is well-known for its hunting and recreational activities. The land consists of a mixture of hardwoods an

Sold Feb 26, 2019

$49,90027.7 acres

County Road 2A, Almond, NY, 14804, Allegany County