New York Houses for Sale with Inactive Properties between $250K and $500K

One-of-a-kind sprawling 203 acre Finger Lakes Farm! This property has it all spanning from the valley bottom where it touches the Fall Creek trout stream to the hilltop pastures. This is an amazing property with so much to offer! The farmhouse is a c

Off Market

$825,000203 acres

4 beds1 baths2,112 sqft

Cortland, NY, 13045, Cayuga County

We are pleased to present this beautiful and tranquil property with a move-in ready home or recreational getaway in Birdsall, NY. This large property boasts 113 acres of trails, food plots, brush, mixed hardwoods, and softwoods nestled quietly in the

Off Market

$499,900113 acres

3 beds1 baths948 sqft

Canaseraga, NY, 14822, Allegany County

Paul Vaicunas

This Amish Farm includes a home, workshop, and valley views on 13.1 acres located in Centerville NY, Allegany County. Opportunity awaits with this well-established Amish home and farm with acreage, and a gorgeous wrap-around porch to enjoy the amazin

Off Market

$249,90013.1 acres

5 beds1 baths2,560 sqft

Centerville, NY, 14744, Allegany County

Girard Kelly

We are pleased to present a beautiful country living property privately tucked away on a hilltop in Stockton, NY. Located just 4.5 miles west of Cassadaga, you will find a private driveway coursing south across a bridge a quarter mile to reveal a won

Off Market

$595,051129 acres

2 beds3 baths1,436 sqft

Stockton, NY, 14784, Chautauqua County

Paul Vaicunas

This secluded country home is accompanied by a barn, pond, pasture, and woods located in the hills of Allegany County, NY. This farmhouse boasts many new features from 2024, including, but not limited to, a new 200 AMP electric service to the house,

House for sale in Allegany County, New York

MAP

$429,90020 acres

4 beds1 baths2,316 sqft

Friendship, NY, 14739, Allegany County

Paul Vaicunas

Welcome to Ames Farms consisting of a house, barns, shop, stocked ponds and free gas located on 60 acres in Dewittville NY, Chautauqua County. This astonishing property offers the potential to build your dreams into a reality. Starting with the 2,655

House for sale in Chautauqua County, New York

VIDEO

$749,90060 acres

4 beds3 baths2,655 sqft

Dewittville, NY, 14728, Chautauqua County

Welcome to your new private country paradise! This property consists of a house, barn-shop, pole barn, and pavilion overlooking the 2 acre pond. The house was built in 1991 and includes over 1,400 sq. ft., 3 bedrooms, and 2 full bathrooms. There are

Off Market

$399,90024 acres

3 beds2 baths1,482 sqft

Perry, NY, 14530, Wyoming County

This 90 acre farm includes a house and barn with breathtaking valley views! The property consists of mostly open land with roughly 60 acres of tillable land. Pastureland surrounds the farm which is perfect for rotational grazing of livestock. There a

Off Market

$399,90090 acres

5 beds3 baths2,560 sqft

Sinclairville, NY, 14782, Chautauqua County

This former Dairy Farm has multiple outbuildings, tillable ground, farmhouse and pastures located just 30 minutes southeast of Ithaca NY and Cayuga Lake. This property consists of 213 acres which is surrounding the house which is situated almost in t

Off Market

$449,900213 acres

3 beds2 baths1,344 sqft

Candor, NY, 13743, Tioga County

Quality country property in Sherman NY, Chautauqua County. The main house was built in 2000 and has 2,784 sq. ft. with 6 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Upon entry is a large mudroom which leads into an open concept kitchen/dining area, living room, a

Off Market

$314,90016.5 acres

6 beds2 baths2,784 sqft

Sherman, NY, 14781, Chautauqua County

Located in the heart of the famous Leatherstocking Region, many opportunities are available with this beautiful property: year-round home, small farm, rental income from land and/or B&B income serving nearby Cooperstown tourism. A strikingly unique g

House for sale in Otsego County, New York

MAP

$349,90010 acres

4 beds2 baths3,200 sqft

Burlington Flats, NY, 13315, Otsego County

Josh Buell

This 100 acre property includes a home, woods, a pond and stunning views with potential for a campground located in Cuba NY, Allegany County. This expansive property offers large acreage with stunning views presenting an incredible potential for a ca

Off Market

$234,900100 acres

3 beds1 baths1,568 sqft

Cuba, NY, 14727, Allegany County

Off Market

Orange, NY, 14812, Schuyler County

Cabin on 50 acres bordering state forest in Orange NY, Schuyler County. This nicely outfitted cabin consists of 2 bedrooms, propane refrigerator, oven range, microwave, generator, wood stove, and an attached open porch. The property also includes mul

This country property includes 63 acres of farm fields, woodlands, and a stream located in Smyrna NY, Chenango County. This property offers privacy with over 1,600 feet of road frontage on the north side and spans across State Highway 80 with mostly

House for sale in Chenango County, New York

$129,90063 acres

4 beds1 baths1,843 sqft

Smyrna, NY, 13464, Chenango County