New York Houses for Sale with Recently Sold Properties between $500K and $750K

Whitetail Properties Real Estate is proud to present the gorgeous acres of the Finger Lakes Exotic Farm! Currently operating as a high fence hunting preserve, this land presents a multitude of opportunities for the aspiring entrepreneur, farmer, hunt

House for sale in Cayuga County, New York

MAP

$698,900136 acres

2 beds1 baths1,152 sqft

2070 Watkins Rd, Moravia, NY, 13118, Cayuga County

Timothy Kent

We are pleased to present this scenic 174-acre farm located in the serene countryside of Avoca, Steuben County, NY. A great opportunity, this diverse property offers a mix of fertile agricultural land, mature timber, and scenic natural features - alo

House for sale in Steuben County, New York

MAP

$649,900175 acres

2 beds1 baths1,032 sqft

9916 County Route 9, Cohocton, NY, 14826, Steuben County

Escape the everyday bustle and relax in complete privacy on this stunning 40+/- acre off-grid retreat in Chautauqua County. Set well off the road and accessed by a private right-of-way (seasonal), this remote and peaceful parcel features a chalet-sty

House for sale in Chautauqua County, New York

MAP

$539,90040 acres

1 beds1 baths1,700 sqft

VL Stebbins Road, Lot#WP001, Forestville, NY, 14062, Chautauqua County

This 174 acre property includes a home, barns, farmland, timberland, and a stream and is located in Avoca NY, Steuben County. Rare opportunity to own a large tract of land in a desirable area that includes a 2-bedroom home, large dairy barn, and mach

$649,900175 acres

2 beds1 baths1,176 sqft

9916 County Road 9, Avoca, NY, 14826, Steuben County

This beautiful country property is situated on 300 acres and includes a house, barns and stream in Woodhull NY. Escape to this scenic location with pleasant views and more than 300 sprawling acres including a home, large barn, and pole barn in southe

Sold Jan 29, 2024

$749,900303 acres

3 beds2 baths1,216 sqft

4837 Owlville Rd, Woodhull, NY, 14898, Steuben County

WELCOME TO THE 100 ACRE WOOD! Don't miss an opportunity to own a little slice of heaven. This majestic private 96 acre homestead is only minutes to the village of Cazenovia & within a 1/2 hour of downtown SYR. There is plenty of acreage for Building

Sold Jul 26, 2021

$739,90096.3 acres

3 beds1 baths1,176 sqft

1601 Grassy Lane Rd, Cazenovia, NY, 13035, Madison County

Allen Olmsted

Canaan Realty

House for sale in Washington County, New York

MAP

$669,000135 acres

3 beds1 baths1,400 sqft

1710 Truthville Road, Whitehall, NY, 12887, Washington County

Successful maple syrup farm with custom craftsman house, complete privacy, stunning views, a trail network, and excellent hunting. Continue the maple syrup harvests or simply enjoy the outdoors on this expansive property. Sitting on the top of the hi

Michael Fudzinski

Don't miss this rare opportunity to buy this 49.99 acre horse farm. This multi-use property features a charming 2018 built ranch house with three bedrooms and two baths. The construction of this home was done with great skill and pride. The kitchen h

House for sale in Otsego County, New York

MAP

$749,00050 acres

3 beds3 baths1,495 sqft

167 County Highway 3A, Unadilla, NY, 13849, Otsego County

Josh Buell

Enjoy complete privacy and seclusion with secure peace of mind. Relax and Regenerate on this little Piece of heaven or work from home comfortably with reliable telephone, fax, DSL and satellite internet. Located near the foothills of The Adirondack M

House for sale in Jefferson County, New York

MAP

$524,90053.3 acres

4 beds2 baths1,506 sqft

3642 Van Brocklin Rd, Lorraine, NY, 13659, Jefferson County

Timothy Kent

We are pleased to present a rare Custom-Built Craftsman Home on 17.5 Scenic Acres - A Hillside Sanctuary in Cohocton, NY. Experience timeless craftsmanship and peaceful country living at this meticulously built 2-bedroom, 2-bathroom home, nestled on

MAP

$524,90017.5 acres

2 beds3 baths1,456 sqft

10324 Ryan Hollow Rd, Cohocton, NY, 14826, Steuben County

Welcome to this beautiful home and acreage located in Alfred NY. History lives in this property! Known as the Gabriel Homestead, the home was built by Archie and Arlene Shaw in 1905. The housing blocks and the roofing tiles were made in Alfred. This

Sold Jun 21, 2023

$539,900138 acres

4 beds2 baths1,908 sqft

5624 State Route 21, Alfred, NY, 14803, Allegany County

Girard Kelly

Tailor-made for equestrian pursuits, farming or a multi-use rural lifestyle, the 100+ acre property offers an impressive blend of infrastructure, income potential and natural beauty with pastures, creeks, woodlots and more.At the heart of the operati

House for sale in Tioga County, New York

MAP

$509,900110 acres

5 beds3 baths1,500 sqft

284 East Spencer Road, LOT#WP001, Spencer, NY, 14883, Tioga County

Timothy Kent

This 271 acre Hunting and Recreational Property includes a Home, Fields, Woods, Ponds, and Stream located in Canisteo NY, Steuben County. Rare opportunity to own a large tract of land in the heart of Steuben County with an impressive layout for quali

Sold Apr 24, 2025

$624,900271 acres

4 beds1 baths1,724 sqft

4092 NY-36, Canisteo, NY, 14823, Steuben County

Perched on a hilltop with expansive 360 views lies Fair Meadows Farm. This spectacular private farm consists of a 4-bedroom house, 2 barns, multiple ponds and a stream. Whether you are an outdoor enthusiast or farmer this ridge top refuge has it all.

Sold Mar 26, 2024

$685,00078.2 acres

4 beds2 baths1,731 sqft

3810 County Route 30, Salem, NY, 12865, Washington County

Michael Fudzinski

PRICE REDUCED!!! MOTIVATED SELLERS!!! Whether you are traveling North or South on State Route 97, let the amazing ride along the Delaware River lead you to your future vacation getaway or forever home. As you turn onto Tuthill Road, a town-maintained

Sold Sep 12, 2024

$565,0009 acres

3 beds2 baths1,824 sqft

142 Tuthill Road, Barryville, NY, 12719, Sullivan County

Clint Carlson

Farm sets nice with a lot of road frontage. Located just minutes to Johnstown and Fonda NY. 100+ good tillable acres, 60-70 acres in pasture with high tensile fencing, balance in woods. 2-story barn with pens for animals and storage. Sheep barn has s

Sold Jan 26, 2022

$700,000204 acres

3 beds2 baths1,973 sqft

658 Old Trail Road, Fonda, NY, 12068, Montgomery County

Kara Posson Reed

Posson Realty LLC

Sold Apr 5, 2012

$698,900326 acres

3 beds1 baths1,500 sqft

County Route 63, Greenwood, NY, 14839, Steuben County

A former dairy farm, known as Warrinerdale Farm, offered for the first time in over 60 years. The property with many updates includes 2 houses, original post and beam dairy barn with 29 stanchions, milk house with 650 gallon stainless steel bulk tank

238 acres including farmland, timberland and recreational land with 1850's homestead and barn. Great property in the eastern part of the Finger Lakes Region in great location near Greek Peak Ski Resort and Hope Lake Lodge with the new Indoor Water Pa

Sold Sep 29, 2011

$569,800239 acres

3 beds1 baths1,500 sqft

2512 County Route 392, Virgil, NY, 13045, Cortland County

Opportunity!! - Act Fast, Will not last at this PRICE! We are pleased to present a beautiful country living property with a track record of producing trophy Whitetails in New York's famed Steuben County. The landowner lives out of state and has recen

Sold Dec 13, 2024

$689,900256 acres

2 beds2 baths1,512 sqft

2990 Woodham Road, Wayland, NY, 14572, Steuben County

We are pleased to present a beautiful country living property privately tucked away on a hilltop in Stockton, NY. Located just 4.5 miles west of Cassadaga, you will find a private driveway coursing south across a bridge a quarter mile to reveal a won

Sold Mar 21, 2025

$595,051129 acres

2 beds3 baths1,436 sqft

5051 Stockton Brocton Rd, Stockton, NY, 14784, Chautauqua County

Welcome to this charming 1870 home steeped in history, now available with its expansive acres, nestled on a hill overlooking scenic views from State Route 32. The property exudes character from the moment you enter, with a prominent "Carriage Stoop"

Sold Mar 26, 2024

$550,00056.1 acres

4 beds1 baths1,666 sqft

11684 State Route 32, Greenville, NY, 12083, Greene County

Mitch Serlin