Hamilton County, NY Houses for Sale with Inactive and Recently Sold Properties between $250K and $500K

Discover this special blend of flora, fauna and fishing along the pristine waters of Butterfield Lake. This extraordinary property offers an rarely-offered retreat accessible only by boat, ensuring ultimate levels of privacy and tranquility experienc

House for sale in Jefferson County, New York

MAP

$299,900148 acres

2 beds1 baths650 sqft

Redwood, NY, 13679, Jefferson County

Timothy Kent

Welcome to your own private oasis, nestled in pristine wilderness. This stunning property offers a 28x60 cabin with two bedrooms and one bath, providing all the amenities you need for comfortable living in the great outdoors. With plenty of storage s

House for sale in Saint Lawrence County, New York

MAP

$299,000143 acres

2 beds1 baths840 sqft

Heuvelton, NY, 13654, Saint Lawrence County

Timothy Kent

Great off-grid hunting camp or vacation getaway with private pond. Located in the heart of the famous Leatherstocking Region of NYS, this is a prime location for hunting whitetail, wild turkey, and grouse or used as a beautiful wildlife preserve in a

House for sale in Otsego County, New York

MAP

$275,00065.9 acres

2 beds576 sqft

Cherry Valley, NY, 13320, Otsego County

Josh Buell

Experience the perfect combination of modern off-grid living and outdoor recreation at this exceptional property in Chautauqua County. This hunting and retreat cabin offers both modern comfort, efficiency, and durability, with a spacious 640 sq ft gr

House for sale in Chautauqua County, New York

MAP

$419,90047 acres

2 beds1 baths640 sqft

Stockton, NY, 14784, Chautauqua County

Paul Vaicunas

35 acres with Log Home, Hunting Cabin, and Pond in Steuben County. Located in a peaceful country setting, this well-maintained home was built in 1987 constructed out of Vermont logs. The one-bedroom log home features a kitchen/dining combination and

Off Market

$329,90035.3 acres

1 beds2 baths960 sqft

Addison, NY, 14801, Steuben County

This 125-acre parcel features front footage on US Rt. 20 with the cabin and a main pond tucked in, hidden above the road making the property both private and accessible year-round. The cabin is move-in ready. Whether you are looking for a family retr

Sold Feb 18, 2025

$349,500125 acres

2 beds1 baths935 sqft

Bridgewater, NY, 13313, Oneida County

Allen Olmsted

Canaan Realty

Off Market

$339,900152 acres

2 beds1 baths800 sqft

Lindley, NY, 14858, Steuben County

A turnkey property with a fully-functioning cabin on 151 acres surrounded by timberland and overlooking the pond. Situated in southern Steuben County is this premium hunting property that has been carefully managed for 50 years. Enjoy the seclusion o

107 acres homestead with Earthen home in Charleston NY, Montgomery County. Own your own Wildlife Sanctuary! Self-reliance lifestyle in upstate NY. This property has it all for any family looking for this kind of opportunity to live off the land! Home

Off Market

$285,900107 acres

3 beds1 baths984 sqft

Fultonville, NY, 12072, Montgomery County

This 95 acre property includes a fully-furnished cabin, pole barn, timberland and streams located in the heart of the Finger Lakes Region. Escape to this quiet and peaceful property centrally located between the popular Canandaigua Lake and Keuka Lak

Off Market

$399,00095.4 acres

1 beds1 baths576 sqft

Branchport, NY, 14418, Yates County

Keith Egresi

276 acres with farmhouse, barns and detached garage in Lisle NY, Broome County. This farm is located in the heart of the countryside in Broome County near the Cortland and Tioga County lines. The barn and pastures are currently being used for raising

Off Market

$489,900277 acres

2 beds1 baths960 sqft

Richford, NY, 13835, Broome County

Off Market

$489,900277 acres

2 beds1 baths1,000 sqft

Marathon, NY, 13803, Cortland County

86 acres horse farm with cabin and trout stream in NE Adirondacks! Long driveway leads to this secluded year-round cabin boasting beautiful views of the Adirondack Mountains and scenic trout stream. Horse pasture is up front along with several outbui

Off Market

$259,90086 acres

2 beds1 baths720 sqft

Lewis, NY, 12950, Essex County

We are pleased to present this beautiful and tranquil property with a move-in ready home or recreational getaway in Birdsall, NY. This large property boasts 113 acres of trails, food plots, brush, mixed hardwoods, and softwoods nestled quietly in the

Off Market

$499,900113 acres

3 beds1 baths948 sqft

Canaseraga, NY, 14822, Allegany County

Paul Vaicunas

We are pleased to present a spectacular timber frame cabin with two ponds and privacy just minutes west Cherry Creek, NY. As you enter the property, the driveway gently winds 260 feet through tall pines opening to a beautiful view of the cabin and a

Off Market

$329,90020 acres

2 beds594 sqft

Cherry Creek, NY, 14006, Chautauqua County

Paul Vaicunas

9 acre Waterfront Land For Sale with Cabin, Amboy, NY! Beautiful Year-Round Finished Cabin on Carterville Pond! 9.46 acres and a year-round cabin with 340 feet of waterfrontage on Carterville Pond. This turn-key 920 square-foot cabin is a masterfully

Sold Mar 31, 2025

$298,9009.46 acres

2 beds1 baths920 sqft

Williamstown, NY, 13493, Oswego County

Jeffrey Abulencia

NY Outdoor Realty LLC

Off Market

$399,00044.6 acres

2 beds1 baths1,000 sqft

Roscoe, NY, 12776, Delaware County

Escape to your own private paradise on 44 secluded acres in the heart of the Catskills. Located just 10 minutes outside of Roscoe, NY, this retreat offers tranquility and natural beauty. At the heart of the property is a stunning spring fed pond, cov

Travis O'Dell

Land & Water Realty

Sold Dec 31, 2012

$349,99527 acres

1 beds1 baths700 sqft

Kildare, NY, 12986, Franklin County

Hidden amongst the towering pines, this Adirondack Mountain Trapper's Cabin is set on 27 private acres - uniquely located adjacent to 8,000 acres of nature preserve and three, large private game preserves managed by the Rockefeller family for wildlif

Marc Christmas

Christmas and Associates

Sold Dec 23, 2021

$275,000107 acres

2 beds1 baths904 sqft

Bernhards Bay, NY, 13028, Oswego County

106 acres Land for Sale with Country Home and Camp, Constantia, NY! Secluded Timberland Near Oneida Lake with Stream on Year-Round Road! 106.7 acre timberland tract with ranch-style house, cabin, barn, and year-round stream only 4 miles North of Onei

Kirk Goodrow

NY Outdoor Realty LLC

Off Market

$398,9002 acres

3 beds1 baths987 sqft

Rushford, NY, 14717, Allegany County

Welcome to this beautiful waterfront cottage on Rushford Lake located in Rushford NY. Take the tree lined driveway to this charming lakefront cottage. The stonework on the covered front porch compliments the interior of the cottage. The living and di