Cattaraugus County, NY Land for Sale with Recently Sold Properties

We are pleased to present the ultimate hunting retreat and building site in Randolph, NY. Welcome to your private outdoor paradise! Nestled in the gentle hills just south of Randolph, NY, this exceptional property offers a rare combination of recreat

MAP

$194,90027 acres

VL Vollentine Road, Lot#WP001, Randolph, NY, 14772, Cattaraugus County

A Western New York famous and award-winning property, the home of the Ellicottville IPRA Championship Rodeo and Nightmare Hayride business is for sale. For over thirty-two years this property has called 25,000 visitors per year from near and far to e

MAP

$8,500,000212 acres

6 beds5,700 sqft

6319 Sommerville Road, Ellicottville, NY, 14731, Cattaraugus County

Looking for a place to deer hunt or camp in the city? This unique property offers the perfect combination of seclusion and accessibility, located just on the edge of the City of Olean and mere minutes from downtown. Nestled on a quiet dead-end road (

MAP

$29,9004.85 acres

VL Cherry St, Lot#WP001, Olean, NY, 14760, Cattaraugus County

A true one-of-a-kind property with an incredible opportunity! The property consists of a spacious 2,976 sq. ft. home with 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and multiple outbuildings all sitting on an incredible 38.5 acres in Olean NY, Cattaraugus County.

$394,90038.5 acres

4 beds2 baths2,976 sqft

1902 East River Road, Olean, NY, 14760, Cattaraugus County

If you've been waiting for a raw, real hunting property where the woods stretch far beyond what you can see, this 76-acre piece of Randolph is it. Set deep off the beaten path with access by private easement, this land is built for the serious hunter

MAP

$219,90076.1 acres

Bunker Hill Rd, Lot#WP001, Randolph, NY, 14772, Cattaraugus County

This property includes a cabin and a pond located on 30 acres in Olean NY, Cattaraugus County. Welcome to your off grid oasis! This cabin is nestled in the southern hills of Olean with nothing but peace and quiet in the middle of the woods. The 30 ac

$109,90030 acres

Indian Creek Road, Olean, NY, 14760, Cattaraugus County

This 50.71 acres is prime hunting ground located just outside the Town of Perrysburg. The acreage is mostly level with some rolling hills. Beautiful mixture of hardwoods with pines scattered throughout the property. Approximately 800 feet into the pr

Sold Jul 3, 2023

$129,90050.7 acres

Mackinaw Road, Perrysburg, NY, 14129, Cattaraugus County

Located just minutes from the heart of Ellicottville, this 5.5-acre parcel offers an exceptional opportunity to build your dream home in a private, scenic setting. With over 400 feet of frontage on Great Valley Creek, the property delivers the soothi

MAP

$49,9005.5 acres

Creek Ridge Road, Lot#WP001, Ellicottville, NY, 14731, Cattaraugus County

Situated on a seasonal road, this secluded seasonal cabin is perfectly staged for making many enjoyable memories and getaway experiences. Tucked away a little more than half a mile, you'll find a cozy, 2-bedroom cabin where you can unplug and enjoy n

MAP

$79,9004.23 acres

2 beds760 sqft

V/L Kent Sub Division Lot#WP001, Hinsdale, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

We are pleased to present 61.4 acres of recreational land in South Valley, NY - Perfect for Hunting, Camping & Building! Escape to the great outdoors with this recreational property on Bone Run Road in South Valley, NY. Located just 4.7 miles from th

MAP

$134,90061.4 acres

VL Bone Run Rd (Off), Lot#WP001, South Valley, NY, 14738, Cattaraugus County

This secluded hunting cabin on 3 acres includes all amenities and is just down the road from Pine Hill State Forest. This 600 sq. ft. cabin has 2 spacious bedrooms with another bedroom in the loft, full bathroom, open living room/dining room area off

Sold Mar 19, 2021

$64,9003 acres

3 beds1 baths600 sqft

Oldro Hill Road, Randolph, NY, 14772, Cattaraugus County

Dan Heisey

We are pleased to present a charming and private country retreat in Randolph, NY. This quiet countryside haven is nestled in the rolling hills of Cattaraugus County. This beautifully updated 3-bedroom, 1.5-bathroom home offers 1,628 square feet of co

MAP

$289,9003.28 acres

3 beds1 baths1,628 sqft

2718 Vollentine Rd, Randolph, NY, 14772, Cattaraugus County

We are pleased to present a beautiful building lot with 1,148 feet of road frontage on Route 242 in Ellicottville, NY. This 10.9+/- acre property is just minutes east of the village center and the ski slope destination for Holimont and Holiday Valley

MAP

$104,90010.9 acres

VL Nys Rte 242 E (Front), Ellicottville, NY, 14731, Cattaraugus County

Building a dream home on a hill couldn’t be better than on a dead end road overlooking beautiful fall color on hills and ridges with family farms below in the valley. This property is suited well for building on your choice of multiple areas to suit

Sold Sep 10, 2021

$114,90043 acres

12905 Mud Lake Road LotWP#001, Kennedy, NY, 14747, Cattaraugus County

We are pleased to present this beautiful parcel of 62.43 acres that is perfect for a dream home or cabin with a view to the hills and countrysidenoted for excellent deer and turkey hunting. If farming is of interest, this property currently has an ac

MAP

$299,90062.4 acres

VL W Hill Rd, Lot#WP001, Cattaraugus, NY, 14719, Cattaraugus County

If you're searching for a private hunting haven, this hidden gem near Little Valley, NY, is the perfect find. Tucked away from the road behind a gated entrance, this property sits deep in the hills, prime territory for big ridge running bucks. Access

MAP

$199,90055.1 acres

VL Bucktooth Run Road, Lot#WP001, Little Valley, NY, 14755, Cattaraugus County

Ever dreamed of owning a Certified Organic farm? This one is unique, specializing in several varieties of squash. Spaghetti, acorn, butternut, delicata and carnival are a few types grown in fertile and nutrient soil here. Secondary is a U-pick portio

Sold Sep 10, 2021

$179,90058.5 acres

12905 Mud Creek Lot#WP001, Kennedy, NY, 14747, Cattaraugus County

We are pleased to present this unique property in the village of South Dayton. Situated in the heart of this country community is a tiny home with the full services of a full-sized residence. This property has access and road frontage on two streets.

MAP

$62,0001.02 acres

1 beds1 baths

18 Second St, South Dayton, NY, 14138, Cattaraugus County

Located in the Northwestern portion of Cattaraugus County, NY this vacant land parcel has a wide variety of habitat and can be used for multiple purposes. There is approximately 1,320 feet of Road Frontage along the paved Cottage Markham Road. Approx

MAP

$239,90094.2 acres

WP01 Cottage Markham Road, South Dayton, NY, 14138, Cattaraugus County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present this exceptional hilltop dream home. Experience the tranquility of country living in this stunning brand-new construction ranch-style home on a quiet road. Situated on a beautiful property with breathtaking

Sold May 16, 2023

$414,90050 acres

3 beds2 baths1,390 sqft

5292 Steward Road, Hinsdale, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

Whitetail Properties is pleased to present a beautiful property quaintly hidden just a third of a mile from the Golden Hill State Forest in Humphrey, NY. Upon approach from County Rt 18 (Humphrey Road), a newly graded and graveled driveway leads you

Sold Dec 11, 2023

$149,90054.2 acres

4204 Humphrey Rd, Great Valley, NY, 14741, Cattaraugus County

This nearly 5-acre wooded parcel is perfectly positioned for a custom home overlooking Great Valley Creek. With good road frontage and direct access from Creek Ridge Road, a private road maintained by the HOA, you'll enjoy both privacy and peace of m

MAP

$49,9004.95 acres

Creek Ridge Road, Lot#WP002, Ellicottville, NY, 14731, Cattaraugus County

Looking for your very own slice of paradise? Look no further than this stunning 45.6-acre property in Hinsdale, NY, complete with a 38.9' camper trailer that sleeps 10!This gorgeous property features everything you need for a comfortable and exciting

Sold Mar 20, 2024

$169,90045.6 acres

431 Yankee Road, Hinsdale, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

In the lil village of Conewango, and in the rolling hills of Southwestern Cattaraugus county sits a small parcel of 1.8 acres with a large home and barn surrounded by neighboring farms. The farmette has multiple gated entrances from Seagar Hill Road

Sold May 30, 2023

$109,9001.8 acres

5 beds2 baths2,560 sqft

12019 Seager Hill Road, Conewango Valley, NY, 14726, Cattaraugus County