Northwest Region, NM Recreational Land for Sale with Recently Sold Properties between 201 and 500 Acres

- 1-9 of 9 Listings

Sort
Recreational Property for sale in Cibola County, New Mexico
VIDEOMAP
$1,450,000305 acres
5 beds3 baths

221/223 Five Gate Road, Pinehill, NM, 87321, Cibola County

On the market for the first time in 40 years! Tallahogan Ranch is a one-of-a-kind +/-305-acre property featuring a main house, guest house, and two traditional Navajo hogans. A rare year-round spring-fed pond attracts wildlife, while towering pondero
Chris Fichtl
Hayden Outdoors
Recreational Property for sale in Cibola County, New Mexico
VIDEOMAP
$699,000232 acres

83 Bear Valley Road, Pinehill, NM, 87321, Cibola County

Bear Valley Ranch spans 231.95 acres in Cibola County, NM. With road frontage, two wells, multiple power access points, and BLM and tribal land access, it's a prime opportunity for hunters, developers, or investors. Featuring a mix of pion-juniper, g
Chris Fichtl
Hayden Outdoors
Recreational Property for sale in Cibola County, New Mexico
VIDEOMAP
$625,000293 acres
3 beds2 baths

36 La Tinaja Trail, Pinehill, NM, 87321, Cibola County

Tinaja Ranch provides a peaceful and beautiful rural escape featuring a 3BR 2BA home complete with city utilities and great year-round access in NM Game Management Unit 12. The +/- 290 acre property is subdivided, making it an excellent investment/de
Lauren Fichtl
Hayden Outdoors
Recreational Property for sale in McKinley County, New Mexico
MAP
$550,000458 acres

BIA 113, Ramah, NM, 87321, McKinley County

Tucked in behind the beautiful Ramah Valley, this beautiful property is located within Game Management Unit 12, which is known for its trophy elk hunting and is currently enrolled in New Mexico Game and Fish’s elk landowner system (EPLUS). Elk, mule
Craig Sanchez
Whitetail Properties Real Estate
Recreational Property for sale in Cibola County, New Mexico
MAP
$324,800406 acres

NM 53-Ice Caves Road, Lot#WP001, Ramah, NM, 87321, Cibola County

This property is located within Game Management Unit 10 and is known for its trophy elk hunting. It is enrolled in the New Mexico Game and Fish’s elk landowner system (EPLUS) for private elk tags and qualifies as a small contributing ranch (SCR). Elk
Craig Sanchez
Whitetail Properties Real Estate
Recreational Property in Cibola County, New Mexico
Sold Jun 3, 2025
$250,000218 acres

TBD CR 33, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Introducing "Homestead Ranch," a 218 acre haven nestled in the serene landscapes of Cibola County, New Mexico. The vast blue skies, pinon trees, sage, sandstone bluffs, and rolling hills create an ideal setting for a cabin or home, allowing residents
Butch Porter
M4 Ranch Group
Recreational Property in Cibola County, New Mexico
Sold
$355,000406 acres

Sec 33, T5N, R14W, Lot#WP001, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

This property is located within Game Management Unit 12, which is known for its trophy elk hunting and is eligible to participate in New Mexico Game and Fish’s elk landowner system (EPLUS). Elk, mule deer, pronghorn and other wildlife utilize this pr
Craig Sanchez
Whitetail Properties Real Estate
Recreational Property in Cibola County, New Mexico
Sold Oct 12, 2023
$331,320331 acres

NM-36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum
Western New Mexico Land Company
Recreational Property in Cibola County, New Mexico
Sold Nov 19, 2018
$236,000382 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Home - United States - New Mexico - Northwest New Mexico - Recreational Land