Fence Lake, NM Inactive and Recently Sold Farms and Ranches, Recreational Land

Introducing "Homestead Ranch," a 218 acre haven nestled in the serene landscapes of Cibola County, New Mexico. The vast blue skies, pinon trees, sage, sandstone bluffs, and rolling hills create an ideal setting for a cabin or home, allowing residents

Sold Jun 3, 2025

$250,000218 acres

TBD CR 33, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Butch Porter

This property is located within Game Management Unit 12, which is known for its trophy elk hunting and is eligible to participate in New Mexico Game and Fish’s elk landowner system (EPLUS). Elk, mule deer, pronghorn and other wildlife utilize this pr

Sold Dec 15, 2022

$355,000406 acres

Sec 33, T5N, R14W, Lot#WP001, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

This rural property is situated just south of Highway 36, along Elk Run Trail, in the Indian Knolls Subdivision. The property has roughly 973+/- feet of dirt/gravel road frontage along its northern boundary, all of which is well-maintained and can be

Off Market

$35,00020 acres

Elk Run Trail, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

The Shadow Canyon Ranch subdivision provides Ranchette lots offering space from neighboring properties making for a desirable location to get away from the big city. The subdivision entrance is from State Road 36 and consists of graveled and well-mai

Sold Aug 23, 2024

$29,00020.2 acres

Sandoval Lane, Lot 48, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Off Market

$530,000645 acres

100 Fence Lake road Fence Lake, NM, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Fence Lake Hunting Ranch, approx 945 acres, located a few miles south of Fence Lake on Hwy 36, is a sleeping gem. Outstanding Elk and Deer hunting. The ranch currently comes with 2 Bull tags but the buyer will have to sign up for the NM elk land owne

Off Market

$750,000945 acres

1111 Hwy 36 South of Fence Lake, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Off Market

$750,000945 acres

1111 Hwy 36 South of Fence Lake, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

West of Fence Lake is one of the best hunting properties in all of Unit 12. Our 645 acre parcel with a 40 acre State Lease really brings in the Big Game- Elk & Deer. Unbelievable WATER SYSTEM. New well 950' with Solar Water Pump. 4 Self Watering T

Off Market

$599,900645 acres

Morano Hill Rd, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Off Market

$35,00020.2 acres

Sandoval Lane, Lot 48, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

West of Fence Lake is one of the best hunting properties in all of Unit 12. Our 645 acre parcel with a 40 acre State Lease really brings in the Big Game- Elk and Deer. 2020 Elk tag. Some very nice Mulies in the area as well. I could not believe all t

Off Market

$375,000645 acres

Morano Hill Rd, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

This lot is part of a subdivided property in the wonderful Indian Knolls Subdivision and features several possibilities for builds thanks to the road that borders the property on three of the sides. There are electric poles along the bordering road m

Sold Jan 14, 2022

$21,50020.6 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Misti Glover

Savvy Lands, LLC

Off Market

40 acres

257 Pine Hill Rd, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

POWER-WATER-SEPTIC ALL INCLUDED---TURNKEY FOR YOU!!!! 40 acres with well, septic, electricity, and 50 amp RV hook up all completed in 2019. Workshop on site with washer with instant hot water heater and dryer as well as ample storage space. Secluded

Off Market

645 acres

Morano Hill Rd, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Located on the southern border of Cibola County, Western Bell Ranch is an untamed paradise sitting at 7,070 feet in elevation, great for the big game enthusiast. Consisting of 946 deeded acres, Western Bell Ranch sits in big game unit 12, which is re

Off Market

$999,000945 acres

TND Highway 36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Seth Craft, ALC

Located on the southern border of Cibola County, Western Bell Ranch is an untamed paradise sitting at 7,070± feet in elevation, great for the big game enthusiast. Consisting of 946± deeded acres, Western Bell Ranch sits in big game unit 12, which is

Off Market

$999,000945 acres

TBD Highway 36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Dan Murphy

Off Market

$999,000945 acres

TBD Highway 36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Butch Porter

Fence Lake, NM. Live in a area of Western NM where there might be more Elk and Deer than People. 160 Acres (2 80-Acre parcels) Great Views!!! The property is Fenced. Power next to Property. Well is needed or haul water in. Received a 2019 Bull Elk Ta

Off Market

160 acres

00 CR 35D, Fence Lake, NM, 87827, Cibola County

PRICE REDUCTION!!!!. Motivated Seller!!! If you want to live in rural Western New Mexico where you will see more critters than people, I have the perfect 50 acres in Fence Lake. Our 50 acres even have power and a well, approx. 3 to 5 gallons a minu

Sold Sep 27, 2023

$69,00050 acres

On Dusty Rd, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

This 632.58 +/- acres-according to Cibola Tax records just north of Fence Lake would make such a beautiful hunting ranch. Great Views of the Ramah mountains to the north. There is a great mixture of PJ trees and grassland on this property. The windmi

Off Market

$410,000633 acres

00 Dusty Ln, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Spanning 7,697+/- deeded acres, Fence Lake Ranch sits in the heart of New Mexico Game Management Unit (GMU) 12 and just 8 miles north and east of the community of Fence Lake. This unimproved acreage is comprised of diverse terrain with rolling ridges

Sold Nov 26, 2019

$2,700,0007,697 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Cody Lujan

Hall and Hall

Off Market

$85,000160 acres

00 Dusty Rd, Fence Lake, NM, 87825, Cibola County

160 Acres (2 80-Acre parcels) Great Views -Fenced Power on Property. Well needed. Elk Tag applied for 2020. Between County Rd 35 and Dusty Rd North of Fence Lake. Good grazing area -Fat Cows Owner Financing GPS: N 34.40.44.11 W 108.430.44 Neighboring

80 acres CASH DEAL ONLY!!!!! Owner will not Carry!!! Well - water lines to barn Barn 1,200 sq ft Partially built apt in barn, approx. 475 sq ft w/ bath Just off Hwy 36, 4 miles north of Fence Lake Great Value- 2 40 acre parcels. GPS: N 32.24924 W 109

Off Market

$70,00080 acres

000 Hwy 36, Fence Lake, NM, 87827, Cibola County