Filters

Active Filters

Remove

New Mexico City: Fence Lake Farms and Ranches Available Sold

Price

–

$0 - $49,999 53

$50,000 - $99,999 6

$100,000 - $249,999 16

$250,000 - $499,999 10

$500,000 - $749,999 2

$1,000,000 and up 3

Custom Price

Parcel Size

–

Custom Size (Acres)

Property Types

–

Bedrooms

–

Custom Beds

Bathrooms

–

Custom Baths

Square Feet

–

1,001 - 2,000 Sq. Ft. 3

4,001+ Sq. Ft. 1

Custom size (Sq. Ft.)

Activities

–

Availability

–

Available 7

Off Market 57

Sold 83

Sale Type

–

Price Reduction

Date Listed

Keywords

Fence Lake, NM Farms and Ranches for Sale with Recently Sold Properties

- 1-25 of 90 Listings

Farm and Ranch for sale in Cibola County, New Mexico

MAP

$230,000195 acres

Mujeras Grande Rd, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

This Beautiful rural property is located within the Santa Rita Land & Cattle Subdivision within Game Management Unit 12, which is known for its trophy elk hunting opportunities. Elk and mule deer, amongst other wildlife, utilize this property. Privat

Craig Sanchez

Whitetail Properties Real Estate

VIDEOMAP

$68,500,00097,825 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

The Atarque Ranch embodies all the characteristics of a large acreage, combination wildlife and livestock New Mexico ranch. The ranch offers a total of 109,308+/- acres, 97,825+/- deeded acres, and 11,483+/- acres of State leased land that is incredi

Sold

26 Chickasaw Lane, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Seize the opportunity to own a remarkable 60-acre property in Fence Lake, NM, strategically located adjacent to expansive state land. This slightly wooded landscape offers unparalleled privacy and direct access to the great outdoors, making it the id

Kevin Branum

Hayden Outdoors

Sold Aug 28, 2023

$530,000645 acres

100 Fence Lake road Fence Lake, NM, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

PRICE REDUCTION. AGAIN!!! Seller wants this property SOLD! West of Fence Lake is one of the best hunting properties in all of Unit 12. Our 645-acre parcel with a 40 acre State Lease really brings in the Big Game- Elk & Deer. Unbelievable WATER SYSTEM

John Conger

National Land Realty

Sold Jun 3, 2025

$250,000218 acres

TBD CR 33, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Introducing "Homestead Ranch," a 218 acre haven nestled in the serene landscapes of Cibola County, New Mexico. The vast blue skies, pinon trees, sage, sandstone bluffs, and rolling hills create an ideal setting for a cabin or home, allowing residents

Butch Porter

M4 Ranch Group

Sold Dec 15, 2022

$355,000406 acres

Sec 33, T5N, R14W, Lot#WP001, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

This property is located within Game Management Unit 12, which is known for its trophy elk hunting and is eligible to participate in New Mexico Game and Fish’s elk landowner system (EPLUS). Elk, mule deer, pronghorn and other wildlife utilize this pr

Craig Sanchez

Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Sold Aug 23, 2024

$29,00020.2 acres

Sandoval Lane, Lot 48, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

The Shadow Canyon Ranch subdivision provides Ranchette lots offering space from neighboring properties making for a desirable location to get away from the big city. The subdivision entrance is from State Road 36 and consists of graveled and well-mai

Craig Sanchez

Whitetail Properties Real Estate

Sold Jun 25, 2021

$149,900160 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

This very private and entirely fenced 160 acre property has all the pertinent features to make it an excellent hunting or weekend retreat, or a place to settle down, build your home, and retire. Enjoy total privacy, trees, meadows, amazing views, exc

Wolfgang Rempen

Ranch Pros Real Estate

$544,000638 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Jan 4, 2023

$264,500306 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Nov 6, 2021

$229,000160 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

$329,00063.9 acres

271 Mujeres Circle, Fence Lake, NM, 87829, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Feb 19, 2021

$191,000351 acres

Mile Marker 4, Highway 117, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

$1,248,000620 acres

3 beds1 baths1,100 sqft

Hwy 36, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Jul 1, 2021

$19,99739 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Jake Huddelston

Landipity

Sold Apr 4, 2021

$231,700331 acres

Rawhide Lane, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold

$15,950,00012,880 acres

7 beds7 baths7,620 sqft

TBD, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Blayne St. James

St. James Sporting Properties

$28,50010.9 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Feb 13, 2025

$289,00021.7 acres

15 Broken Arrow Way, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Aug 9, 2020

$339,000974 acres

3 beds2 baths1,600 sqft

southside Rawhide Lane, Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Feb 27, 2023

$95,000146 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Jun 21, 2020

$314,000334 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Jun 5, 2025

$490,000160 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold May 15, 2023

$87,50013.5 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Sold Dec 1, 2020

$95,50049.8 acres

Fence Lake, NM, 87315, Cibola County

Gary Blum

Western New Mexico Land Company

Similar Properties

Home - United States - New Mexico - Northwest New Mexico - Cibola County - Fence Lake - Farms and Ranches