New York Inactive and Recently Sold Horse Properties between $250K and $500K

Quality country property in Sherman NY, Chautauqua County. The main house was built in 2000 and has 2,784 sq. ft. with 6 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms. Upon entry is a large mudroom which leads into an open concept kitchen/dining area, living room, a

Off Market

$314,90016.5 acres

6 beds2 baths2,784 sqft

Sherman, NY, 14781, Chautauqua County

A true one-of-a-kind property with an incredible opportunity! The property consists of a spacious 2,976 sq. ft. home with 4 bedrooms, 2 full bathrooms, and multiple outbuildings all sitting on an incredible 38.5 acres in Olean NY, Cattaraugus County.

Horse Property in Cattaraugus County, New York

Off Market

$394,90038.5 acres

4 beds2 baths2,976 sqft

Olean, NY, 14760, Cattaraugus County

One-of-a-kind property with views soaring over the vast valley in Farmersville NY. This 153 acre parcel has it all including 85 acres of wooded land on the east side of the property, and 58 acres of tillable land on west side of the property. This is

Off Market

$499,900154 acres

Farmersville, NY, 14101, Cattaraugus County

Off Market

Grove, NY, 14884, Allegany County

This Amish Farm includes 55 acres with a house, barn, workshop and pond in Grove NY, Allegany County. The acreage consists of several acres of fenced-in pasture, a mix of hardwoods and pine trees, dense brushy area, and a spring-fed pond. This proper

Off Market

$149,90055 acres

Grove, NY, 14884, Allegany County

This 24+ acre property includes a 4 bedroom, 1 bath home, a horse barn, and frontage on Baker Creek located in Allen NY. This nice country home has many recent updates including vinyl replacement windows throughout the home. The kitchen has plenty of

Off Market

$224,90024 acres

4 beds1 baths1,820 sqft

Angelica, NY, 14709, Allegany County

This 42 acre Amish farm consists of an organic field, maple sugar bush, gravel pit, a pond and valley views located in Centerville NY, Allegany County. This beautiful Amish home has 7 bedrooms, 1.5 bathrooms, and 2,758 sq. ft. The home also consists

Off Market

$292,90042 acres

7 beds1 baths2,758 sqft

Centerville, NY, 14735, Allegany County

This former dairy farm consists of 63+- acres with barns, tillable land, woods and a pond located in Independence NY, Allegany County. Great property for a beef farm, horse farm, or a hobby farm. One of the barns has a concrete feeding area and a nic

Off Market

$198,90063 acres

Independence, NY, 14897, Allegany County

An excellent opportunity to own a nice sized farm already situated for a Dairy Operation to milk approximately 50 cows with brand new updated milk-house in Deerfield NY. This farm property comes with 4 barns that total nearly 8,200 square feet of spa

Horse Property in Oneida County, New York

Off Market

$489,900241 acres

Poland, NY, 13431, Oneida County

Dan Heisey

This 26+ acre farm is located in Newark Valley on State Route 38 directly across from the Newark Valley High School. This operating Amish farm includes a two story farmhouse, large milking barn, sheds, and a workshop. The home includes a large additi

Horse Property in Tioga County, New York

Off Market

$269,90026.9 acres

Newark Valley, NY, 13811, Tioga County

Jim Wilson

Off Market

$269,90026.9 acres

Newark Valley, NY, 13811, Tioga County

Jim Wilson

Nestled at the foot of the Berkshires lies this beautiful ranch situated on 97 acres in the Stephentown Valley. With fields, hardwoods, two ponds, trout stream, stable/barn and a beautiful homestead, this is truly a one-of-a-kind estate. The location

Horse Property in Rensselaer County, New York

Off Market

$629,80097 acres

4 beds3 baths3,352 sqft

Stephentown, NY, 12168, Rensselaer County

Scott VanRoy

This unique 4 bedroom, 2 bath Farmhouse with Large Garage and Barn on 68 acres is a turn-key operational Beef Farm. The 2,100+ sq ft house was completely remodeled in 2001 including new flooring, electric, plumbing, heating, insulation with newer roo

Off Market

$394,90068 acres

4 beds2 baths2,100 sqft

Randolph, NY, 14772, Cattaraugus County

169 acres Farm Land for Sale with Woods, Brookfield NY! Perfect for Homestead and Horses, Across from State Land! Incredible setting with 3,484 acres of state forest across the road where you see wildlife daily and the opportunity to live a secluded

Sold Jan 23, 2025

$349,900169 acres

Waterville, NY, 13480, Oneida County

Kirk Goodrow

NY Outdoor Realty LLC

Sold Feb 1, 2023

$749,900139 acres

3 beds2 baths2,764 sqft

Addison, NY, 14801, Steuben County

139 acre Horse Farm with Log Home in Addison NY, Steuben County. Escape to this country retreat located in the hills of southern Steuben County, just north of the Pennsylvania line. You will quickly notice the pride and effort of the current owner as

Dan Heisey

This farm on 18 acres has about 5 acres of tillable land and 10 acres of open pastureland, several barns and a house in Hinsdale NY. There is a 44 x 120 barn that is capable of holding up to 70 head with milking parlor intact and milks 8 head at a ti

Off Market

$169,90018 acres

6 beds1 baths2,276 sqft

Hinsdale, NY, 14743, Cattaraugus County

Dan Heisey

Incredibility rare opportunity to find nearly 400 acres less than 49 miles to midtown Manhattan. Cimarron Ranch is a large acreage site for a multitude of options from private estate, retreat opportunities, recreational and much more. Existing horse

Horse Property in Putnam County, New York

Off Market

$2,295,000382 acres

Putnam Valley, NY, 10579, Putnam County

Allen Olmsted

Canaan Realty

Horse Property in Chenango County, New York

Sold Mar 23, 2024

$139,00044 acres

Sherburne, NY, 13460, Chenango County

Sixty acres of land located in North Norwich, NY. Close to 30 tillable acres currently in corn. Good soils that can grow just about anything that one desires. Property boarders the Chenango river. where one can enjoy canoeing, kayaking and fishing. E

Kara Posson Reed

Posson Realty LLC

Horse Property in Tompkins County, New York

Sold Jun 14, 2023

$549,90041.9 acres

2 beds1 baths726 sqft

Groton, NY, 13073, Tompkins County

Quality-built horse farm on 41 acres in Lansing NY near Ithaca, Cornell University, and Cayuga Lake. Horse Lovers look no further! If you have been looking for a place to call home and operate a turn-key horse farm, this could be it. This property wa

Brian Jackson